Overview

"The compelling story of leading physicists in Germany--including Peter Debye, Max Planck, and Werner Heisenberg--and how they accommodated themselves to working within the Nazi state in the 1930s and '40s. After World War II, most scientists in Germany maintained that they had been apolitical or actively resisted the Nazi regime, but the true story is much more complicated. In Serving the Reich, Philip Ball takes a fresh look at that controversial history, contrasting the career of Peter Debye, director of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physics in Berlin, with those of two other leading physicists in Germany during the Third Reich: Max Planck, the elder statesman of physics after whom Germany's premier scientific society is now named, and Werner Heisenberg, who succeeded Debye as director of the institute when it became focused on the development of nuclear power and weapons. Mixing history, science, and biography, Ball's gripping exploration of the lives of scientists under Nazism offers a powerful portrait of moral choice and personal responsibility, as scientists navigated ""the grey zone between complicity and resistance."" Ball's account of the different choices these three men and their colleagues made shows how there can be no clear-cut answers or judgment of their conduct. Yet, despite these ambiguities, Ball makes it undeniable that the German scientific establishment as a whole mounted no serious resistance to the Nazis, and in many ways acted as a willing instrument of the state. Serving the Reich considers what this problematic history can tell us about the relationship between science and politics today. Ultimately, Ball argues, a determination to present science as an abstract inquiry into nature that is ""above politics"" can leave science and scientists dangerously compromised and vulnerable to political manipulation."

Full Product Details

9780226204574

Table of Contents

Reviews

A fair-minded and meticulous assessment of the generally weak-kneed response, and especially of the actions of three non-Jewish physicists in Germany, all Nobel laureates. -- Jewish Daily Forward An excellent, concise account of the German side of the most dramatic era in the history of physics. -- Michigan War Studies Review I have been studying this subject for decades, but I found new things in Ball's book. He has put the material together in an accessible way, and there is an extensive bibliography for people who would like to dig deeper. -- Wall Street Journal The biggest problem with the behavior of Heisenberg, Planck, and Debye is not, Ball suggests, that they failed to actively resist the Nazis. After all, he writes, 'it is a brave person who asserts without hesitation that he or she would have done better.' Instead, it is their failure even to engage with the idea that they, as scientists, bore some responsibility for the work they did and the regime under which they did it. Being an 'apolitical scientist' is itself a political decision, Ball argues, and as his book demonstrates, it is not always the right one. -- Physics Today This is an outstanding work about the social responsibility of scientists, exemplified by considering the actions of three Nobelist physicists during the Nazi regime in Germany: Max Planck, Peter Debye, and Werner Heisenberg. . . . Ball, a journalist and prolific author chronicles the pressures on these men to expel Jews from their posts before the war and to pursue war research and support the Nazi ideology during the war. The retrospective furor about their alleged collaboration, accommodation, or resistance motivates Ball to reconstruct their dilemmas and responses. The conflicting accounts of Heisenberg's role in the atomic bomb project are carefully reviewed and their ambiguity noted and discussed. In these episodes, Ball thoughtfully navigates the nuances of attaching motives to acts, avoiding justifying the more strident contemporary accusations and exoneration. This is a stunning cautionary tale, well researched and told. Essential. -- Choice Serving the Reich is a remarkable achievement--not only for its popularization of historical debates but also for the depth of its analysis. Both the layperson interested in the moral dilemma of physicists under Hitler and the historian familiar with the controversial debates will find Ball's account highly instructive. -- Physics Today

"""The story of physicists under Hitler has been studied frequently and in great depth, though no account has aimed to be quite as comprehensive as this one by Ball, a writer of exceptional versatility and productivity. . . . This is an impressive assessment; Ball's judgments on his three protagonists are well-reasoned, nuanced, and, in my view, fair.""-- ""Guardian"" ""I have been studying this subject for decades, but I found new things in Ball's book. He has put the material together in an accessible way, and there is an extensive bibliography for people who would like to dig deeper. . . . Why should we be interested in this now? There is a lesson to be learned. Before a fanatic regime came to power, Germany had the greatest scientific establishment ever created. In a very few years it evaporated. The ambience for doing science is fragile. I have colleagues in Pakistan who are informed that all true science can be found only in the Quran. China has spent fortunes creating a class of scientists, but not one truly revolutionary discovery in any science has come from China. Revolutionary science thrives on dissent. Without it, science becomes mundane.""-- ""Wall Street Journal"" ""A fascinating account of the moral dilemmas faced by German physicists working within Nazism. Impeccably researched.""-- ""Tablet"" ""A fine book.""-- ""Times Literary Supplement"" ""An engrossing and disturbing book.""-- ""History Today"" ""An examination of the response of German scientists to the rise of the Third Reich and its interference with their work. . . . How much did Nazism compromise its scientists? In this polished account, Ball finds that the jury is still out, even as the evidence mounts and the pursuit of firsthand records and documentary testimony continues.""-- ""Kirkus"" ""Asks important questions, not just about twentieth-century German science but about the nature of science and the response of scientists to the political world we perforce inhabit. All scientists should read and ponder its contents.""-- ""Times Higher Education"" ""Ball does an outstanding service by reminding us how powerful and sometimes confusing the pressures were and how it was not implausible to think that scientists could and should stay 'above politics.' . . . Packed with dramatic, moving, and even comical moments.""-- ""Nature"" ""Ball provides an interesting twist on Werner Heisenberg's failure to realize a Nazi atomic bomb. The dominant narrative, constructed by wartime Dutch-US physicist Samuel Goudsmit, was that the 'unfree society' of the Nazi physicists closed them to the necessary information. What really happened was that the rest of the scientific world gradually closed its doors to the Nazis because it could not tolerate their society.""-- ""New Scientist"" ""Ball's book shows what can happen to morality when cleverness and discovery are valued above all else.""-- ""New Statesman"" ""By paying more attention than others have done to the role of the Nobel Prize-winning physicist Peter Debye, director of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute of Physics (KWIP) in Berlin from 1936 to 1940, Ball adds to our knowledge of an already well-studied topic. He embeds this work within an engagingly written broader interpretation aimed at a general readership, in which he compares Debye's career with those of Max Planck and Werner Heisenberg.""-- ""Isis"" ""Education lays a veneer over our emotions, but it is disconcertingly thin. Perhaps the most powerful of those emotions--or drives--is survival: few of us are heroes in dangerous circumstances and, without question, life was dangerous for many during Hitler's Reich (especially for thinkers, 'dissidents' and 'outsiders, ' and one could be all three at once). . . . Ball makes the ethical conundrums and dilemmas very clear. They are questions that everyone--not simply scientists, politicians, teachers--must still confront.""-- ""Australian"" ""German science led the world until Hitler ruined it, as British science writer Ball claims in this fine account of how it happened. . . . Almost all non-Jewish German scientists fretted, compromised, and looked after their own interests. Others have vilified them as collaborators, but Ball, no polemicist, thinks this was a moral failure, common and not confined to Germans. This is an important, disturbing addition to the history of science.""-- ""Publishers Weekly"" ""Much has been written about physics in the period between 1930 and 1945, but Ball's book is more than just a good history. In exploring the actions and ethical dilemmas of three physicists (Werner Heisenberg, Max Planck, and Peter Debye) working in Nazi Germany, he also argues against the notion that scientists can ever be truly 'above politics'--a debate that remains intensely relevant more than seventy years after the events described in his book.""-- ""Physics World, Book of the Year Shortlist"" ""A fair-minded and meticulous assessment of the generally weak-kneed response, and especially of the actions of three non-Jewish physicists in Germany, all Nobel laureates.""-- ""Jewish Daily Forward"" ""An excellent, concise account of the German side of the most dramatic era in the history of physics.""-- ""Michigan War Studies Review"" ""This is an outstanding work about the social responsibility of scientists, exemplified by considering the actions of three Nobelist physicists during the Nazi regime in Germany: Max Planck, Peter Debye, and Werner Heisenberg. . . . Ball, a journalist and prolific author chronicles the pressures on these men to expel Jews from their posts before the war and to pursue war research and support the Nazi ideology during the war. The retrospective furor about their alleged collaboration, accommodation, or resistance motivates Ball to reconstruct their dilemmas and responses. The conflicting accounts of Heisenberg's role in the atomic bomb project are carefully reviewed and their ambiguity noted and discussed. In these episodes, Ball thoughtfully navigates the nuances of attaching motives to acts, avoiding justifying the more strident contemporary accusations and exoneration. This is a stunning cautionary tale, well researched and told. Essential.""-- ""Choice"" ""Ball's real interests lie elsewhere, in what he calls the 'grey zone between complicity and resistance.' It is one of the strengths of Serving the Reich that in surveying this territory the analysis is not unduly flattering to the moral and political certainties of the present.""-- ""Prospect"" ""Serving the Reich is a remarkable achievement--not only for its popularization of historical debates but also for the depth of its analysis. Both the layperson interested in the moral dilemma of physicists under Hitler and the historian familiar with the controversial debates will find Ball's account highly instructive.""-- ""Physics Today"""

I have been studying this subject for decades, but I found new things in Ball's book. He has put the material together in an accessible way, and there is an extensive bibliography for people who would like to dig deeper. . . . Why should we be interested in this now? There is a lesson to be learned. Before a fanatic regime came to power, Germany had the greatest scientific establishment ever created. In a very few years it evaporated. The ambience for doing science is fragile. I have colleagues in Pakistan who are informed that all true science can be found only in the Quran. China has spent fortunes creating a class of scientists, but not one truly revolutionary discovery in any science has come from China. Revolutionary science thrives on dissent. Without it, science becomes mundane. -- Wall Street Journal A fascinating account of the moral dilemmas faced by German physicists working within Nazism. Impeccably researched. -- Tablet A fine book. -- Times Literary Supplement An engrossing and disturbing book. -- History Today An examination of the response of German scientists to the rise of the Third Reich and its interference with their work. . . . How much did Nazism compromise its scientists? In this polished account, Ball finds that the jury is still out, even as the evidence mounts and the pursuit of firsthand records and documentary testimony continues. -- Kirkus Asks important questions, not just about twentieth-century German science but about the nature of science and the response of scientists to the political world we perforce inhabit. All scientists should read and ponder its contents. -- Times Higher Education Ball does an outstanding service by reminding us how powerful and sometimes confusing the pressures were and how it was not implausible to think that scientists could and should stay 'above politics.' . . . Packed with dramatic, moving, and even comical moments. -- Nature Ball provides an interesting twist on Werner Heisenberg's failure to realize a Nazi atomic bomb. The dominant narrative, constructed by wartime Dutch-US physicist Samuel Goudsmit, was that the 'unfree society' of the Nazi physicists closed them to the necessary information. What really happened was that the rest of the scientific world gradually closed its doors to the Nazis because it could not tolerate their society. -- New Scientist Ball's book shows what can happen to morality when cleverness and discovery are valued above all else. -- New Statesman By paying more attention than others have done to the role of the Nobel Prize-winning physicist Peter Debye, director of the Kaiser Wilhelm Institute of Physics (KWIP) in Berlin from 1936 to 1940, Ball adds to our knowledge of an already well-studied topic. He embeds this work within an engagingly written broader interpretation aimed at a general readership, in which he compares Debye's career with those of Max Planck and Werner Heisenberg. -- Isis Education lays a veneer over our emotions, but it is disconcertingly thin. Perhaps the most powerful of those emotions--or drives--is survival: few of us are heroes in dangerous circumstances and, without question, life was dangerous for many during Hitler's Reich (especially for thinkers, 'dissidents' and 'outsiders, ' and one could be all three at once). . . . Ball makes the ethical conundrums and dilemmas very clear. They are questions that everyone--not simply scientists, politicians, teachers--must still confront. -- Australian German science led the world until Hitler ruined it, as British science writer Ball claims in this fine account of how it happened. . . . Almost all non-Jewish German scientists fretted, compromised, and looked after their own interests. Others have vilified them as collaborators, but Ball, no polemicist, thinks this was a moral failure, common and not confined to Germans. This is an important, disturbing addition to the history of science. -- Publishers Weekly Much has been written about physics in the period between 1930 and 1945, but Ball's book is more than just a good history. In exploring the actions and ethical dilemmas of three physicists (Werner Heisenberg, Max Planck, and Peter Debye) working in Nazi Germany, he also argues against the notion that scientists can ever be truly 'above politics'--a debate that remains intensely relevant more than seventy years after the events described in his book. -- Physics World, Book of the Year Shortlist The story of physicists under Hitler has been studied frequently and in great depth, though no account has aimed to be quite as comprehensive as this one by Ball, a writer of exceptional versatility and productivity. . . . This is an impressive assessment; Ball's judgments on his three protagonists are well-reasoned, nuanced and, in my view, fair. -- Guardian A fair-minded and meticulous assessment of the generally weak-kneed response, and especially of the actions of three non-Jewish physicists in Germany, all Nobel laureates. -- Jewish Daily Forward An excellent, concise account of the German side of the most dramatic era in the history of physics. -- Michigan War Studies Review This is an outstanding work about the social responsibility of scientists, exemplified by considering the actions of three Nobelist physicists during the Nazi regime in Germany: Max Planck, Peter Debye, and Werner Heisenberg. . . . Ball, a journalist and prolific author chronicles the pressures on these men to expel Jews from their posts before the war and to pursue war research and support the Nazi ideology during the war. The retrospective furor about their alleged collaboration, accommodation, or resistance motivates Ball to reconstruct their dilemmas and responses. The conflicting accounts of Heisenberg's role in the atomic bomb project are carefully reviewed and their ambiguity noted and discussed. In these episodes, Ball thoughtfully navigates the nuances of attaching motives to acts, avoiding justifying the more strident contemporary accusations and exoneration. This is a stunning cautionary tale, well researched and told. Essential. -- Choice Ball's real interests lie elsewhere, in what he calls the 'grey zone between complicity and resistance.' It is one of the strengths of Serving the Reich that in surveying this territory the analysis is not unduly flattering to the moral and political certainties of the present. -- Prospect Serving the Reich is a remarkable achievement--not only for its popularization of historical debates but also for the depth of its analysis. Both the layperson interested in the moral dilemma of physicists under Hitler and the historian familiar with the controversial debates will find Ball's account highly instructive. -- Physics Today

A fair-minded and meticulous assessment of the generally weak-kneed response, and especially of the actions of three non-Jewish physicists in Germany, all Nobel laureates. --Jewish Daily Forward The biggest problem with the behavior of Heisenberg, Planck, and Debye is not, Ball suggests, that they failed to actively resist the Nazis. After all, he writes, 'it is a brave person who asserts without hesitation that he or she would have done better.' Instead, it is their failure even to engage with the idea that they, as scientists, bore some responsibility for the work they did and the regime under which they did it. Being an 'apolitical scientist' is itself a political decision, Ball argues, and as his book demonstrates, it is not always the right one. --Physics Today I have been studying this subject for decades, but I found new things in Ball's book. He has put the material together in an accessible way, and there is an extensive bibliography for people who would like to dig deeper. --Wall Street Journal This is an outstanding work about the social responsibility of scientists, exemplified by considering the actions of three Nobelist physicists during the Nazi regime in Germany: Max Planck, Peter Debye, and Werner Heisenberg. . . . Ball, a journalist and prolific author chronicles the pressures on these men to expel Jews from their posts before the war and to pursue war research and support the Nazi ideology during the war. The retrospective furor about their alleged collaboration, accommodation, or resistance motivates Ball to reconstruct their dilemmas and responses. The conflicting accounts of Heisenberg's role in the atomic bomb project are carefully reviewed and their ambiguity noted and discussed. In these episodes, Ball thoughtfully navigates the nuances of attaching motives to acts, avoiding justifying the more strident contemporary accusations and exoneration. This is a stunning cautionary tale, well researched and told. Essential. --Choice An excellent, concise account of the German side of the most dramatic era in the history of physics. --Michigan War Studies Review Serving the Reich is a remarkable achievement--not only for its popularization of historical debates but also for the depth of its analysis. Both the layperson interested in the moral dilemma of physicists under Hitler and the historian familiar with the controversial debates will find Ball's account highly instructive. --Physics Today

Author Information

Philip Ball is a freelance writer and broadcaster whose many books on the interactions of the sciences, the arts, and the wider culture include Bright Earth, Curiosity, Patterns in Nature, How to Grow a Human, The Modern Myths, The Elements, and, most recently, The Book of Minds, all also published by the University of Chicago Press. His book Critical Mass won the 2005 Aventis Prize for Science Books. Ball is also the 2022 recipient of the Royal Society's Wilkins-Bernal-Medawar Medal for contributions to the history, philosophy, or social roles of science. He trained as a chemist at the University of Oxford and as a physicist at the University of Bristol, and he was an editor at Nature for more than twenty years. He lives in London.

Tab Content 6

Customer Reviews

Recent Reviews

Countries Available