Overview
A persuasive argument against ""forgive and forget""
Full Product Details
Author: Thomas Brudholm ,
Jeffrie G. Murphy ,
John C. Torpey
Publisher: Temple University Press,U.S.
Imprint: Temple University Press,U.S.
Dimensions:
Width: 15.20cm
, Height: 2.30cm
, Length: 22.90cm
Weight: 0.494kg
ISBN: 9781592135660
ISBN 10: 1592135668
Pages: 256
Publication Date: 15 February 2008
Audience:
Professional and scholarly
,
Professional & Vocational
Format: Hardback
Publisher's Status: Active
Availability: In Print
This item will be ordered in for you from one of our suppliers. Upon receipt, we will promptly dispatch it out to you. For in store availability, please contact us.
Reviews
"""Resentment's Virtue represents an important counterpoint to the privileged status accorded to the logic of forgiveness in the transitional justice and reparations literatures. Brudholm illustrates nicely that 'negative emotions' are not only understandable in the aftermath of mass atrocity, but that they possess a moral component that is often ignored by the boosters of reconciliation."" Andrew Woolford, co-author of Informal Reckonings: Conflict Resolution in Mediation, Restorative Justice and Reparations ""Brudholm provides a view that is likely to be controversial, namely, that resentment can be just as much of an acceptable outcome to collective violence...Brudholm makes the case that resentment might be just as permissible as the tendency to forgive."" Contemporary Sociology ""Every now and then a book is published that makes you think - and rethink - the position you have on a specific issue. Danish philosopher Thomas Brudholm's Resentment's Virtue ranks among the candidates for becoming one of those books for theologians and philosophers of religion...It states its case clear and with a consistent and sufficient backing: it makes clear to the reader that to forgive others for atrocities and crimes might have severe consequences, and that it might even be in the interest of morality to refuse to forgive...Brudholm's book will be regarded as an important contribution"" Ars Disputandi ""A persuasive and compelling account that urges readers not simply to assume or to presume that forgiveness is the obvious best course. International Journal of Transitional Justice ""[Brudholm's] analysis cuts across disciplines in order to bring to the surface discourses on forgiveness and resentment shared by law, ethics and psychology, and bring these into contact with victim testimony and Jean Amery's writings, which offer the position of both testimony and critical reflection... This is a timely book which has much to offer on the current scholarly debate on forgiveness."" Holocaust Studies, Summer 2009 ""[The] case studies are sublime investigations of the claim according to which forgiveness and reconciliation are (morally) superior to resentment and the refusal to forgive (and maybe especially) in the aftermath of collective violence and atrocities... The TRC [Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa] hearings are commented on convincingly by Brudholm. Many of the (original) quotes make impressive reading and provide direct insights into the problematic aspects of the ethics of reconciliation... Brudholm's book surely is an important contribution to the discussion on the ethics of forgiveness, and it might be called a brilliant analysis."" The Journal of Moral Education Sept 2009 ""Brudholm has written an excellent book, in every sense of the word 'excellent' (Aristos!). It deserves to be read by various audiences...Brudholm's book should be of interest not just to those interested in responses to mass atrocity; not just to those interested in transitional grasps for justice; not just to philosophers and psychologists; and not just to ethicists interested in moral emotions and behaviors. This book deserves to be read by a large group, including, most important, politicians, occupying powers, foreign ministries, and policy institutes."" H-Net, Sept 2009 ""In his thoughtful, elegant book Resentment's Virtue, Thomas Brudholm makes a powerful case for the appropriateness of resentment and the refusal to forgive... Brudholm's sensitive reading of Jean Amery will serve as a reminder that forgiveness must be earned-and that sometimes this is impossible.""--Passions in Context issue 3, 2013"
Resentment's Virtue represents an important counterpoint to the privileged status accorded to the logic of forgiveness in the transitional justice and reparations literatures. Brudholm illustrates nicely that 'negative emotions' are not only understandable in the aftermath of mass atrocity, but that they possess a moral component that is often ignored by the boosters of reconciliation. -Andrew Woolford, co-author of Informal Reckonings: Conflict Resolution in Mediation, Restorative Justice and Reparations Resentment's Virtue offers a much-needed corrective to the current fashionable enthusiasm for reconciliation and forgiveness as appropriate and desirable responses to unspeakable atrocities and the persons who authorized or committed them. It also provides a detailed analysis of Jean Amery's contribution to the alternative argument that continuing outrage and refusal to forgive constitute justifiable moral reactions to such atrocities. It should stimulate renewed discourse on a troublesome subject. -Lawrence L. Langer, author of Holocaust Testimonies: The Ruins of Memory and, most recently, Using and Abusing the Holocaust In Resentment's Virtue, Thomas Brudholm rightly takes issue with some of the lazy assumptions concerning both the putative benefits of reconciliation and the assumed negativity of anger directed against those who have committed human rights atrocities... The results are a thoughtful and interesting... treatment... [T]he themes in this book will be of interest across the transitional justice disciplines and if Brudholm compels people to take Amery seriously, I think he will regard his work as well done. -International Affairs
Resentment's Virtue represents an important counterpoint to the privileged status accorded to the logic of forgiveness in the transitional justice and reparations literatures. Brudholm illustrates nicely that 'negative emotions' are not only understandable in the aftermath of mass atrocity, but that they possess a moral component that is often ignored by the boosters of reconciliation. Andrew Woolford, co-author of Informal Reckonings: Conflict Resolution in Mediation, Restorative Justice and Reparations Brudholm provides a view that is likely to be controversial, namely, that resentment can be just as much of an acceptable outcome to collective violence...Brudholm makes the case that resentment might be just as permissible as the tendency to forgive. Contemporary Sociology Every now and then a book is published that makes you think - and rethink - the position you have on a specific issue. Danish philosopher Thomas Brudholm's Resentment's Virtue ranks among the candidates for becoming one of those books for theologians and philosophers of religion...It states its case clear and with a consistent and sufficient backing: it makes clear to the reader that to forgive others for atrocities and crimes might have severe consequences, and that it might even be in the interest of morality to refuse to forgive...Brudholm's book will be regarded as an important contribution Ars Disputandi A persuasive and compelling account that urges readers not simply to assume or to presume that forgiveness is the obvious best course. International Journal of Transitional Justice [Brudholm's] analysis cuts across disciplines in order to bring to the surface discourses on forgiveness and resentment shared by law, ethics and psychology, and bring these into contact with victim testimony and Jean Amery's writings, which offer the position of both testimony and critical reflection... This is a timely book which has much to offer on the current scholarly debate on forgiveness. Holocaust Studies, Summer 2009 [The] case studies are sublime investigations of the claim according to which forgiveness and reconciliation are (morally) superior to resentment and the refusal to forgive (and maybe especially) in the aftermath of collective violence and atrocities... The TRC [Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa] hearings are commented on convincingly by Brudholm. Many of the (original) quotes make impressive reading and provide direct insights into the problematic aspects of the ethics of reconciliation... Brudholm's book surely is an important contribution to the discussion on the ethics of forgiveness, and it might be called a brilliant analysis. The Journal of Moral Education Sept 2009 Brudholm has written an excellent book, in every sense of the word 'excellent' (Aristos!). It deserves to be read by various audiences...Brudholm's book should be of interest not just to those interested in responses to mass atrocity; not just to those interested in transitional grasps for justice; not just to philosophers and psychologists; and not just to ethicists interested in moral emotions and behaviors. This book deserves to be read by a large group, including, most important, politicians, occupying powers, foreign ministries, and policy institutes. H-Net, Sept 2009
Resentment's Virtue represents an important counterpoint to the privileged status accorded to the logic of forgiveness in the transitional justice and reparations literatures. Brudholm illustrates nicely that 'negative emotions' are not only understandable in the aftermath of mass atrocity, but that they possess a moral component that is often ignored by the boosters of reconciliation. Andrew Woolford, co-author of Informal Reckonings: Conflict Resolution in Mediation, Restorative Justice and Reparations Brudholm provides a view that is likely to be controversial, namely, that resentment can be just as much of an acceptable outcome to collective violence...Brudholm makes the case that resentment might be just as permissible as the tendency to forgive. Contemporary Sociology Every now and then a book is published that makes you think - and rethink - the position you have on a specific issue. Danish philosopher Thomas Brudholm's Resentment's Virtue ranks among the candidates for becoming one of those books for theologians and philosophers of religion...It states its case clear and with a consistent and sufficient backing: it makes clear to the reader that to forgive others for atrocities and crimes might have severe consequences, and that it might even be in the interest of morality to refuse to forgive...Brudholm's book will be regarded as an important contribution Ars Disputandi A persuasive and compelling account that urges readers not simply to assume or to presume that forgiveness is the obvious best course. International Journal of Transitional Justice [Brudholm's] analysis cuts across disciplines in order to bring to the surface discourses on forgiveness and resentment shared by law, ethics and psychology, and bring these into contact with victim testimony and Jean Amery's writings, which offer the position of both testimony and critical reflection... This is a timely book which has much to offer on the current scholarly debate on forgiveness. Holocaust Studies, Summer 2009 [The] case studies are sublime investigations of the claim according to which forgiveness and reconciliation are (morally) superior to resentment and the refusal to forgive (and maybe especially) in the aftermath of collective violence and atrocities... The TRC [Truth and Reconciliation Commission of South Africa] hearings are commented on convincingly by Brudholm. Many of the (original) quotes make impressive reading and provide direct insights into the problematic aspects of the ethics of reconciliation... Brudholm's book surely is an important contribution to the discussion on the ethics of forgiveness, and it might be called a brilliant analysis. The Journal of Moral Education Sept 2009 Brudholm has written an excellent book, in every sense of the word 'excellent' (Aristos!). It deserves to be read by various audiences...Brudholm's book should be of interest not just to those interested in responses to mass atrocity; not just to those interested in transitional grasps for justice; not just to philosophers and psychologists; and not just to ethicists interested in moral emotions and behaviors. This book deserves to be read by a large group, including, most important, politicians, occupying powers, foreign ministries, and policy institutes. H-Net, Sept 2009
Author Information
Thomas Brudholm is Research Fellow at the Danish Institute for International Studies.
