Overview

First providing a new and thought-provoking interpretation of the Spinoza Controversy of around 1800, and the Controversy’s reprise in the 1920s, this work then makes a compelling case for the Controversy’s ongoing vital relevance. If the Spinoza Controversy has historically been one of the few times our mainstream discourse has adequately identified and opposed the fatal early German romantic flaw which still lies at the heart of Western scientific naturalism – the unfounded belief that necessity relations are really, and not ideally, ontological – then the Controversy’s lens is invaluable now, in an era characterized by our still deeply underestimated and mischaracterized environmental nihilism, a multifaceted condition in line with which we cognitively and philosophically nullify the actual external world while also increasingly physically rendering it nothing by removing, dismantling, and consuming it. In linking this nihilism with a romantic understanding of necessity over two centuries old, Snow shows how not only our environmental nihilism, but also our increasing belief in worlds even less real than Spinozistic naturalism’s – such as the worlds ostensibly brought into being only through economic or, now, sheerly informatic, types of necessity – calls out for opening up, for a third and final time, the questions the Controversy affords us unique ways of asking regarding the purpose, the limits, and perhaps even the future, of Western theoretical rationality itself.  

Full Product Details

Author:   Katherine C. Snow
Publisher:   Springer Nature Switzerland AG
Imprint:   Palgrave Macmillan
ISBN:  

9783032030443

ISBN 10:   3032030447
Pages:   240
Publication Date:   06 March 2026
Audience:   Professional and scholarly ,  College/higher education ,  Professional & Vocational ,  Postgraduate, Research & Scholarly
Format:   Hardback
Publisher's Status:   Forthcoming
Availability:   Not yet available  
This item is yet to be released. You can pre-order this item and we will dispatch it to you upon its release.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction.- 2. The Spinoza Controversy: Jacobi’s claims about the irredeemable price of romanticism and their neglected significance for environmental questions.- 3. The Spinoza Controversy Redux: Inter-war Germany’s self-consciously “religious” thinking about nature and the dispute over its boundaries.- 4. Interlude, I: The rise of modern physics and cosmology out of the same inter-war culture.- 5. Interlude, II: The post-War global destruction of the living world by humans and the use of the sciences to try to convey the resulting crisis and need for change.- 6. A Spinoza Controversy for our Time: Ecological nihilism, the limits of science, and the contemporary void of experience without meaning.- 7. Conclusion.

Reviews

Author Information

Katherine C. Snow is an environmental philosopher and currently a research associate at Princeton University. She received her PhD from the University of Edinburgh in 2021.

Tab Content 6

Author Website:  

Countries Available

All regions