Inconsistency and Indecision in the United States Supreme Court

Author:   Matthew P. Hitt
Publisher:   The University of Michigan Press
ISBN:  

9780472131365


Pages:   234
Publication Date:   30 May 2019
Format:   Hardback
Availability:   In stock   Availability explained
We have confirmation that this item is in stock with the supplier. It will be ordered in for you and dispatched immediately.

Our Price $211.07 Quantity:  
Add to Cart

Share |

Inconsistency and Indecision in the United States Supreme Court


Add your own review!

Overview

The United States Supreme Court exists to resolve constitutional disputes between the lower courts and the other branches of government, allowing elected officials, citizens, and businesses to act without legal uncertainty. American law and society function more effectively when the Court resolves these ambiguous questions of Constitutional law. Since lower courts must defer to its reasoning, the Court should also promulgate clear and consistent legal doctrine, giving a reason for its judgment that a majority of justices support. Yet a Court that prioritizes resolving many disputes will at times produce contradictory sets of opinions or fail to provide a rationale and legal precedent for its decision at all. In either case, it produces what is known as an unreasoned judgment. Conversely, a Court that prioritizes logically consistent doctrine will fail to resolve many underlying disputes in law and society. Inconsistency and Indecision in the United States Supreme Court demonstrates that over time, institutional changes, lobbied for by the justices, substantially reduced unreasoned judgments in the Court's output, coinciding with a reduction in the Court's caseload. Hence, the Supreme Court historically emphasized the first goal of dispute resolution, but evolved into a Court that prioritizes the second goal of logically consistent doctrine. As a result, the Court today fails to resolve more underlying questions in law and society in order to minimize criticism of its output from other elites. In so doing, the modern Court often fails to live up to its Constitutional obligation.

Full Product Details

Author:   Matthew P. Hitt
Publisher:   The University of Michigan Press
Imprint:   The University of Michigan Press
Weight:   0.465kg
ISBN:  

9780472131365


ISBN 10:   0472131362
Pages:   234
Publication Date:   30 May 2019
Audience:   Professional and scholarly ,  Professional & Vocational
Format:   Hardback
Publisher's Status:   Active
Availability:   In stock   Availability explained
We have confirmation that this item is in stock with the supplier. It will be ordered in for you and dispatched immediately.

Table of Contents

Reviews

The author sets out to accomplish an ambitious task and, in my view, achieves that task. The phenomenon under investigation has not received sufficient attention in the extant literature and the author's treatment of it is both wide and deep. --Wendy Martinek, Binghamton University Hitt addresses an important and interesting question in the study of law and courts: What happens when the Supreme Court issues a decision in a case but fails to establish a clear precedent? Hitt provides a systematic and sophisticated analysis that sheds significant light on these important phenomena. An engaging and elegant read, this book will be enjoyed by anyone with interests in judicial politics or legal development. --Ryan C. Black, Michigan State University


The author sets out to accomplish an ambitious task and, in my view, achieves that task. The phenomenon under investigation has not received sufficient attention in the extant literature and Matthew B. Hitt's treatment of it is both wide and deep. --Wendy Martinek, Binghamton University


The author sets out to accomplish an ambitious task and, in my view, achieves that task. The phenomenon under investigation has not received sufficient attention in the extant literature and Matthew B. Hitt's treatment of it is both wide and deep. - Wendy Martinek, Binghamton University


Author Information

Matthew P. Hitt is Assistant Professor of Political Science at Colorado State University.

Tab Content 6

Author Website:  

Customer Reviews

Recent Reviews

No review item found!

Add your own review!

Countries Available

All regions
Latest Reading Guide

ls

Shopping Cart
Your cart is empty
Shopping cart
Mailing List